In many ways, finding a legitimate agent is far more difficult that finding a reputable publisher. Literary agents today still have the reputation of gatekeepers in the publishing industry, but this role is complex. While they can open doors for authors, they also have the responsibility of filtering content for publishers, which contributes to their reputation as gatekeepers.

One of the primary reasons literary agents are seen as gatekeepers is because they control access to traditional publishers. Major publishing houses like Penguin Random House, HarperCollins, and Simon & Schuster rarely accept unsolicited submissions directly from authors. This means that for most writers seeking a traditional book deal, finding an agent is the first and often the only viable step toward publication.

Agents act as gatekeepers by curating and filtering submissions, only passing along manuscripts they believe have the potential to succeed in the market. As a result, only a small fraction of authors make it past this first barrier. For many, the process of finding an agent feels like trying to unlock an exclusive club, with access to larger publishers restricted to those fortunate enough to be chosen.

Agents are also highly selective because they balance artistic merit with commercial potential. Even if a manuscript is wonderfully written, it may still be rejected if the agent believes it won’t sell. This emphasis on marketability reflects the realities of today’s publishing industry, where profitability, of course, is the highest priority.

As a result, authors writing unconventional, experimental, or niche works may struggle to find representation unless their work aligns with current market trends. If a project doesn’t fit the trend, it may be rejected, regardless of its literary merit.

Another challenge for authors is the limited capacity of agents. Agents receive hundreds of queries every month, but can only represent a few new clients at any given time. This scarcity of opportunity forces agents to be highly selective, focusing only on the most promising and commercially viable projects.

This process is so frustrating for us writers. Even strong manuscripts are often overlooked due to sheer volume. The limited bandwidth of agents contributes to their reputation as gatekeepers so, getting an agent’s attention is a daunting, competitive process that leaves little room for newcomers or debut writers. Here’s a deeper look into what this means, the pros and cons, and how this perception affects the publishing landscape.

Are Literary Agents Still Relevant?

About Writing     |     The Hollow Man Series, International Espionage​

​