The role of literary agents as gatekeepers has both positive and negative effects on authors. On the positive side, agents act as quality control for the publishing industry. By carefully selecting and filtering manuscripts, agents ensure that only polished, high-quality work reaches publishers. This helps maintain high literary standards and increases the likelihood that readers will encounter well-edited, professionally crafted books.

Agents possess in-depth knowledge of the publishing industry, including what editors and publishers are currently looking for. This expertise allows agents to provide valuable feedback, guiding authors to revise and improve their manuscripts before submission. An agent’s familiarity with industry trends also helps ensure that the work is well-positioned to succeed. Beyond editorial input, agents bring significant value to authors by negotiating contracts.

However, there are also downsides to this gatekeeping role that can and do frustrate authors. One of the biggest challenges is subjectivity. An agent’s personal taste may not align with either the quality of a manuscript or its potential appeal to readers. This subjectivity means that a book that might resonate deeply with a wide audience may never make it past an agent’s desk. To make matters worse, agents tend to favor projects that align with what is currently popular in the market. For example, if political thrillers or spy novels are in vogue, those genres will receive more attention, leaving authors whose work falls outside these categories struggling to find representation. Focus on market trends can eliminate creative innovation, since unconventional works are often overlooked in favor of more predictable, trend-following projects.

The process of querying agents can be as emotionally and mentally exhausting as the proverbial Postal Worker Syndrome. Many authors spend months or even years submitting query letters, sample chapters, and synopses without receiving any offers of representation. Rejections, without detailed feedback, can feel demoralizing and discourage even talented writers from continuing.

Pros & Cons of Agents As Gatekeepers

About Writing     |     The Hollow Man Series, International Espionage​

​